Matthew’s Pizzeria, a longtime Baltimore institution that has been serving customers for more than 80 years, has been named Maryland’s selection on a new national list highlighting the best pizza spots in all 50 states.
The list, titled “50 Best Pizza Spots Across the U.S., One in Every State” by Only in Your State, selected one pizzeria from each state, considering regional pizza styles, awards, and longstanding local popularity.
According to the publication, the rankings were based on a combination of editorial research, customer reviews, awards, quality, accessibility, affordability, hours, inclusivity, value, innovation, and creativity. The criteria were weighted to reflect the overall experience and relevance of each establishment, using information from public reviews, expert input, and previous recognition. The publication acknowledged that the rankings are ultimately subjective and may change over time.
Located at 3131 Eastern Avenue in Baltimore’s Highlandtown neighborhood, Matthew’s Pizzeria dates back to 1943, making it the city’s oldest pizzeria. Founded by Matthew Cacciolo and his son Frank, the business began as a small father-and-son bakery serving tomato pies to neighborhood residents.
Matthew’s is particularly known for its distinctive Baltimore-style pizza, featuring handmade dough pressed into an oiled pan and baked into a thick, puffy crust reminiscent of focaccia. One of its signature offerings is the crab pizza, topped with backfin crab meat, sweet onion, and Old Bay seasoning.
In its write-up, the national list highlighted the restaurant’s history, unique pizza style, and reputation as a neighborhood institution that has served generations of Baltimore residents.
According to its website, Matthew’s remains locally owned and operated and has previously received recognition from Food Network, Baltimore Magazine, and The Baltimore Sun. The restaurant was also previously named Maryland’s best pizza by Yahoo Food. Matthew’s Pizzeria is located at 3131 Eastern Avenue, Baltimore, MD 21224. Its website is matthewspizza.com.